"Corbyn is for remain and reform"

Posted by economia 12/12/2019 3 Comment(s) Economia Blog,



Hilary Wainwright is a British sociologist, political activist and socialist feminist, best known for being editor of Red Pepper magazine.


I met her in her office, to discuss Brexit and the coming elections. She was optimistic that the Labor Party will win the elections and definite that Jeremy Corbyn is pro-remain.




Has the Labor Party a clear position on Brexit?

On the Left there was a debate about EEC participation already in the ‘70s.  Harrold Wilson was against participation, but he left it up to the people to decide in the referendum.

Jeremy Corbyn’s position in the referendum was for remain. He did go and speak in lot of places. However, the official Labor party campaign was notoriously bad – mainly done with Cameron, so was kind of discredited. I think Corbyn was not short of allowed to participate in it. A close friend of Corbyn, Alan Simpson, who is very pro-remain, said actually Corbyn was excluded from the campaign. So he never built up a profile for being for remain. He has always been for remain and reform – he has never been just remain, but a critical remain.

He also has quite a record of being very internationalist, not just across the world, but within Europe. So he worked close with the Left in Greece, Spain and Portugal. I do not agree with those who say that Corby, in his heart of hearts, is a leave person. I think he is genuinely short of open, but can see the argument for remain and reform. And John MacDonald is definitely for remain and reform – and they are very close, Corbyn and MacDonald – they are political brothers.


What drove working class people, especially in the North, to vote for Brexit?

I think the Brexit vote was very diverse. You had the people in the North who felt abandoned really. It was the nature of the referendum – this gives everyone a vote – a chance to kind of kick the establishment by saying “no”. That tendency was strengthened by the mainstream, mass circulation media, like the Daily Mail and the Sun, plus campaigning by UKIP. On the other hand, the Labor Party didn’t have its own campaign and ended up having aligned itself with the establishment.

Many voters in the South (small business and so on) don’t want the regulation – what they see as the red tape of Europe.  That is one thing. But then the people in the North are not anything to do with that. They are more about that short of protest feeling.

And to some degree it is reinforced by the immigration issue, which is more about protesting against low wages. It is an issue which can be addressed quite easily by proper legislation. And indeed Europe is beginning to shift towards a requirement, the Posted Directive, that wage level should be based on trade union rights and the going rates in the host country – not the country of origin.


What about the City – was it pro-Brexit?

I think the City is not pro-Brexit. Obviously there are different bits of the City – banks, hedge funds etc. The banks and the institutions serving the financial transactions of the City don’t want to see financial transactions moving to Frankfurt – they are anti-Brexit. The others do not really care. Finance is so mobile that it does not really matter.

Hedge funds benefit from Brexit through speculation on the pound. Maybe they have a vested interest in avoiding financial regulation. Europe, whether now or in the future, will mean the possibility of regulating international financial flows.


Brexit will dominate election’s campaign?

Because of extreme levels of inequality, poverty and precariousness amongst the mass of people, issues other than Brexit – social and economic issues – force themselves to the fore. It is not just that Labor Party is stressing those issues. It is also many actors shaping public opinion.

For example there has been a report about food banks from a very well-known charity, saying that 94% of those using the food banks are actually desperate – in a short of starvation. Or you have the film by Ken Loach, which is about the big economy and is very powerful – and it will have quite an impact. So these kind of daily issues are forcing themselves on the people’s consciousness.

Even the FT I was reading yesterday, Robert Shrimsley, he says we should not underestimate Corbyn, partly because of this, because the issues of inequality are short of really in your face and cannot be avoided.

And also Johnson’s attempts to kind of mask them by offering all these money; it cannot work because people are actually experiencing austerity (delayed hospital appointments and so on), so those promises of money in the future, particularly coming from somebody who nobody can trust. It is not really convincing people.

For that reason I think that Labor will be able to get over those social issues without appearing to be ignoring the current political reality.


Is there a prospect of a coalition government between the main pro-remain parties, i.e. the Labor and the Liberals?

There is a problem with the Liberals. Their new leader has obviously decided that the only way she can establish a distinct identity is by distancing herself from Corbyn, by defining herself in terms of remain and attacking Corbyn for being too left-wing.

I think a lot of remain people, that would vote for Liberals where Liberals are second to the Tories, they can see that the only remain party that could get into government is Labor. So there will be some tactical voting where Liberals are second but otherwise I think remain voters will come to Labor.

There is also recognition that Corbyn did play a key role in stopping no-deal Brexit. They defined themselves, in the last days of the Johnson’s parliament, in a very positively European way.

Probably there will also be some Labor voters voting Liberals where they are second to the Tories. Remain voters are quite intelligent and well educated, so they get to be able to make those judgments quite easily.


What about the SNP?

The Scotts are very positively for remain. They have always said they believe in independence in Europe. So there has been quite a preparation for this position.

Hard Brexit is not off the table – Johnson could do everything. A hard Brexit would make more likely further devolution in Scotland.

So if there is a no deal Brexit, or if there is Brexit in the end, that favors those arguments for independence. But that is not to say that without Brexit, within Europe, there would not also be a pressure. So there will be a pressure towards independence. In particular if there is a Labor government.

Maybe there will be some deal with the SNP. There is a controversy about a governmental agreement, where Labor will accept a new independence referendum in Scotland. I think John MacDonald has said he would.

There has been a tradition in the Labor Party of being opposed to independence, seeing it as a nationalist diversion from class, but since a lot of independence people are working class people who mainly went to the independence movement against Thatcher and austerity. Corbyn has not cut himself off the independence lobby. It is also gaining some ground inside the Labor Party in Scotland. A Labor government will create favorable conditions for independence.


Except Brexit and economic policy, are there any other important issues at stake on the coming election?

We are suffering from an incomplete democratic revolution and now there is an opportunity for completing it. We still have a constitutional monarchy. A lot of the antidemocratic features of our system have to do with the executive, the Prime Minister, acting in the name of the Crown.

The problem is not the Queen has power, but that the formal position of the Crown in the Parliament enables the Prime Minister to take action, like declare war, in the name of the Crown. This has been eroded by the pressure for debates over Iraq War or the Falkland’s War – required to come to Parliament – and then over Brexit too. There is a short of movement that is de facto challenging that. Now it needs to be consolidated in writing in some kind of constitutional assembly, some kind of democratic process drawing up a written Constitution.

On the other hand, a possible Johnson’s win on the elections will be a disaster, because he will continue to use those undemocratic powers. Therefore it is very crucial to defeat him.

3 Comment(s)

15/12/2019, 09:51:16 AM

Do You Seek Funds To Pay Off Credits and Debts? { EllinasFinances@gmail.com } Is Here To Put A Stop To Your Financial Problems. We Offer All Kinds Of Loan (Personal Loan, Commercial Loan, etc.) We Give Out Loan With An Interest Rate Of 2%. Interested Applicants Should Contact Us Via Email: EllinasFinances@gmail.com Please Fill the Application Form Below:- Complete Name:- Loan Amount Needed:- Loan Duration:- Purpose Of Loan:- City / Country:- Telephone:- How Did You Hear About Us: If You Are Interested To Get A Loan Then Kindly Write Us With The Loan Requirement. Please, Contact Us via Email: EllinasFinances@gmail.com ,,,

Charlotte Müller:
16/12/2019, 09:41:43 AM

Hello, My name is Charlotte Müller, I'm a Private lender. Do you need a quick, long or short term loan with a relatively low interest rate as low as 3%? Is the difficulty of the economy affecting you this year? or have you been denied a loan by your bank or other financial institution? We offer safe loans email me via (moonlightloanfirm@gmail.com) * Do you seek funds to pay off debts? * Do you seek finance to set up your own business? * Do you seek loans to carry out large projects? * Do you need a loan in less than 24 hours? * Are you in need a quick loan for various purposes?   If your answer is yes, I can be of assistance to you. * I can offer you a loan of up to €5,000,000 Euro. * You can Choose between 1 to 30 years to repay. * You can Choose between Monthly and Annual repayments Plan. * Flexible Loan Terms. Please if you are interested check back with me through this email address: | moonlightloanfirm@gmail.com | You have 100% guarantee that you will receive your loan at the end of this loan transaction. We are passionate making financial inclusion count. Our loans and investment products are designed to offer you convenience and value. With Moonlight Loan Firm, you can say goodbye to all your financial crisis and difficulties as we are certified, trustworthy, reliable, efficient, fast and dynamic Warm Regards Mrs. Charlotte Müller

Dr ikhide:
02/01/2020, 10:28:13 AM

I contacted Dr Ikhide via his E-mail ikhidespecial@gmail.com Its a miracle that I am alive today. I encounter HERPES SIMPLEX VIRUS (HSV1/2) for good four (4) years, six (6) months and twelve (12) day with my calculations, before I meet the great Dr Ikhide I am  from Fresno California, united state of America and I was affected with herpes virus. Herpes is a viral infection cause by the Herpes simplex virus, marked by painful, watery blister in the skin or mucous membrane or on the genitals. This was what I suffered for good four years. I have visited CVS Pharmacy in Fresno for treatment but no improvement. I meet Dr Ikhide online while I was searching for herpes cure I read a testimony about his work. I give a try that now becomes a testimony in my life. I contacted Dr Ikhide via his E-mail ikhidespecial@gmail.com and he did not responds to me in time and I went back to the same testimony for his mobile number and I called him immediately  +1(267)527-9481  And he respond to my call. He welcome me as a daughter and I explain my four years situation to him and he said is done just as I have contacted him and I believed in him. Dr Ikhide sends me some herbal medication for herpes cure and he gave me instruction on what to do and I obeyed his instruction. Changes started after three days of applying the herbal medication. I went to the same CVS Pharmacy in Fresno for test and i was herpes negative. I do not know how to thanks Dr Ikhide for saving my life. To God be the Glory, I am living healthy with my family today.Indeed, Dr Ikhide is a great man WhatsApp him now +1(267)527-9481 God bless Dr Ikhide for his good work...   

Leave a Comment