What educated people from poor countries make of the “brain drain” argument

Posted by economia 30/08/2018 5 Comment(s) The Economist-Open Future,

 

 

Halting emigration is no way to fix dysfunctional countries

 

 

HIGHLY skilled immigrants from poorer parts of the world tend to be welcomed by most rich countries. In the debate about migration in the West, foreign surgeons and software engineers are not maligned in the way that farm workers and waiters frequently are, even though they have been migrating in ever greater numbers. In the decade to 2010-11 the number of university-educated migrants in the G20, a group of large economies that hosts two-thirds of the world’s migrants, grew by 60% to 32m, according to the OECD, a club of mostly rich countries.

 

On the face of it, this sounds like a win-win trend, as host countries benefit from the migrants’ skills, who in turn benefit from the more stable economic environment they enter. But some development economists fret that it is bad for the migrants’ home countries. They argue that “brain drain” from poor countries is robbing those countries of the people they need to escape poverty. Others are sceptical about the theory, arguing that the benefits of remittances from exiles and the new skills which returning migrants bring home far outweigh the damage of their leaving.

 

What do educated people in poor countries make of these debates? “There are sectors, what you might think of as humanities or maybe arts subjects, where skilled manpower is in oversupply,” says Yasin Sadiq Mayanja, a Ugandan government economist. “If we had opportunities we would leave.” He believes that it makes sense for highly educated people to take their skills elsewhere rather than being unproductive at home. The only group of people he worries about is Ugandan doctors, who find it relatively easy to emigrate. In 2015 just 69% of the country’s health-care jobs were filled. 

 

 

Others emphasise that choosing whether to stay or migrate is not a simple economic decision. Farah Muneer’s two siblings work for Microsoft in America and the Australian government. They left even though her family is wealthy enough to afford a comfortable life back home. Ms Muneer, who now works as an economics researcher in Dhaka, would have stayed away too. But being the youngest child and also unmarried, she was expected to return home to live with her parents in Bangladesh after finishing a masters’ degree in Britain.

 

Sometimes people back home judge those who leave quite harshly, says Violeta Hernandez, a management consultant who left Guatemala to be with her Italian husband. “Most of the people would think that someone who migrates has an easy life abroad,” she says. But being abroad has not lessened her love for her home country, she says, pointing out that for many Guatemalan migrants, the country is always in their thoughts. “If we start a business abroad… we’re always thinking about how to bring some benefits to Guatemala.”

 

Others feel that the “brain drain” debate is based on the wrong premise. Elnathan John, a Nigerian author who has satirised the obstacles that he and his fellow Nigerians face in migrating to, or even getting short-term visas for, Western countries, objects to framing migration in those terms. “A lot of the argument around ‘skilled migrants’ is classist because it makes a distinction between the human value of skilled people and that of ‘unskilled’ migrants, whatever that means,” says Mr John, who lives in Berlin. “It also assumes that if all skilled persons stay in a dysfunctional country, that country will somehow get better.”

 

Venezuela, one of the few countries which is suffering a “drain” of people, well-educated or not, demonstrates the short-sightedness of that assumption. It is precisely the country’s dysfunction and economic collapse that has driven its people abroad, among them around a third of its doctors. There is little sense that anything would improve if more people stayed, so those left behind are loth to criticise those who are leaving. “Doctors get paid like $10 a month if they’re lucky,” says Luisa, an activist. “Not many people want to criticise them. It’s logical. They would do the same.” Even though she herself has been getting more work with international organisations in the country owing to the exodus of skilled people, Luisa says that she constantly thinks about leaving. “Living here is an act of faith.”

 

 

Find more about Open Future here

5 Comment(s)

Morgan Smith:
31/08/2018, 02:12:12 PM
Reply

I AM FINIALLY OUT FINANCIAL BONDAGE THANKS TO MOORE LOAN COMPANY (mooreloancompany@yahoo.com) Or text +1(414) 454-9493.. Good day everyone,I can’t hide this great testimony that took place in my life I will love everyone to know it and be a partaker of this, that is why I want to share it to the whole world by placing this advert on classifieds, I am Mr Morgan Smith by name, I live in Chicago, United State, I want to thank ROBBINSON MOORE for his kindness upon my family life, I never knew that there is still a sincere and trustworthy lender like this on the internet and on earth. Just some days I was in search for a loan of $ 150,000.00, As I was in search of funds to start up a business. I was scammed about $15,000.00 dollars and I decided not to involve my self in such business again. But a Friend of mine introduced me to a loan firm due to my appearance and doings and also my complains to her. And I told her that I am not interested in any loan deal anymore but she told me that there is still a sincere lender who she will recommend me to, And she gave me the details of this man who is called MOORE ROBBINSON. And I really put a trial and I am most greatful and lucky today, I was given a loan amount of $95,000,00 Dollars by this great firm MOORE LOAN COMPANY. If you are in need of a genuine, Sincere, durable and a truth worthy loan lender or financial assistance and also you know you can be reliable and trusted, capable of paying back at the due / duration time of the funds I will advice you to send your contact to them via email @[ mooreloancompany@yahoo.com] OR Text +1(414) 454-9493 .

Morgan Smith:
31/08/2018, 02:12:12 PM
Reply

I AM FINIALLY OUT FINANCIAL BONDAGE THANKS TO MOORE LOAN COMPANY (mooreloancompany@yahoo.com) Or text +1(414) 454-9493.. Good day everyone,I can’t hide this great testimony that took place in my life I will love everyone to know it and be a partaker of this, that is why I want to share it to the whole world by placing this advert on classifieds, I am Mr Morgan Smith by name, I live in Chicago, United State, I want to thank ROBBINSON MOORE for his kindness upon my family life, I never knew that there is still a sincere and trustworthy lender like this on the internet and on earth. Just some days I was in search for a loan of $ 150,000.00, As I was in search of funds to start up a business. I was scammed about $15,000.00 dollars and I decided not to involve my self in such business again. But a Friend of mine introduced me to a loan firm due to my appearance and doings and also my complains to her. And I told her that I am not interested in any loan deal anymore but she told me that there is still a sincere lender who she will recommend me to, And she gave me the details of this man who is called MOORE ROBBINSON. And I really put a trial and I am most greatful and lucky today, I was given a loan amount of $95,000,00 Dollars by this great firm MOORE LOAN COMPANY. If you are in need of a genuine, Sincere, durable and a truth worthy loan lender or financial assistance and also you know you can be reliable and trusted, capable of paying back at the due / duration time of the funds I will advice you to send your contact to them via email @[ mooreloancompany@yahoo.com] OR Text +1(414) 454-9493 .

Morgan Smith:
31/08/2018, 02:12:12 PM
Reply

I AM FINIALLY OUT FINANCIAL BONDAGE THANKS TO MOORE LOAN COMPANY (mooreloancompany@yahoo.com) Or text +1(414) 454-9493.. Good day everyone,I can’t hide this great testimony that took place in my life I will love everyone to know it and be a partaker of this, that is why I want to share it to the whole world by placing this advert on classifieds, I am Mr Morgan Smith by name, I live in Chicago, United State, I want to thank ROBBINSON MOORE for his kindness upon my family life, I never knew that there is still a sincere and trustworthy lender like this on the internet and on earth. Just some days I was in search for a loan of $ 150,000.00, As I was in search of funds to start up a business. I was scammed about $15,000.00 dollars and I decided not to involve my self in such business again. But a Friend of mine introduced me to a loan firm due to my appearance and doings and also my complains to her. And I told her that I am not interested in any loan deal anymore but she told me that there is still a sincere lender who she will recommend me to, And she gave me the details of this man who is called MOORE ROBBINSON. And I really put a trial and I am most greatful and lucky today, I was given a loan amount of $95,000,00 Dollars by this great firm MOORE LOAN COMPANY. If you are in need of a genuine, Sincere, durable and a truth worthy loan lender or financial assistance and also you know you can be reliable and trusted, capable of paying back at the due / duration time of the funds I will advice you to send your contact to them via email @[ mooreloancompany@yahoo.com] OR Text +1(414) 454-9493 .

Morgan Smith:
31/08/2018, 02:12:13 PM
Reply

I AM FINIALLY OUT FINANCIAL BONDAGE THANKS TO MOORE LOAN COMPANY (mooreloancompany@yahoo.com) Or text +1(414) 454-9493.. Good day everyone,I can’t hide this great testimony that took place in my life I will love everyone to know it and be a partaker of this, that is why I want to share it to the whole world by placing this advert on classifieds, I am Mr Morgan Smith by name, I live in Chicago, United State, I want to thank ROBBINSON MOORE for his kindness upon my family life, I never knew that there is still a sincere and trustworthy lender like this on the internet and on earth. Just some days I was in search for a loan of $ 150,000.00, As I was in search of funds to start up a business. I was scammed about $15,000.00 dollars and I decided not to involve my self in such business again. But a Friend of mine introduced me to a loan firm due to my appearance and doings and also my complains to her. And I told her that I am not interested in any loan deal anymore but she told me that there is still a sincere lender who she will recommend me to, And she gave me the details of this man who is called MOORE ROBBINSON. And I really put a trial and I am most greatful and lucky today, I was given a loan amount of $95,000,00 Dollars by this great firm MOORE LOAN COMPANY. If you are in need of a genuine, Sincere, durable and a truth worthy loan lender or financial assistance and also you know you can be reliable and trusted, capable of paying back at the due / duration time of the funds I will advice you to send your contact to them via email @[ mooreloancompany@yahoo.com] OR Text +1(414) 454-9493 .

Josef Lewis:
04/09/2018, 05:31:00 AM
Reply

Good-day, I'm Josef Lewis. A reputable, legitimate & accredited lender. We give out loan of all kinds in a very fast and easy way, Personal Loan, Car Loan, Home Loan, Student Loan, Business Loan, Inventor loan, Debt Consolidation. etc Get approved for a business or personal loans today and get funds within same week of application. These personal loans can be approved regardless of your credit and there are lots of happy customers to back up this claim. But you won’t only get the personal loan you need; you will get the cheapest one. This is our promise: We guarantee The lowest rate for all loans with free collateral benefits. We strive to leave a positive lasting impression by exceeding the expectations of my customers in everything I do. Our goal is to treat you with dignity and respect while providing the highest quality service in a timely manner. No social security Number required and no credit check required, 100% Guaranteed. Kindly respond immediately using the details below if interested in a loan and be free of scams.. Email: progresiveloan@yahoo.com Call/WhatsApp: +16626183756 Website: https://progresivefunding.wordpress.com

Leave a Comment